The story is a very promising one and is the kind of thriller that I enjoy the most, however the execution wasn’t, in my opinion, to Kellerman’s usual high standard. It seems that the whole book was working to a big ending. Kellerman does an excellent job of building up a very tense and intriguing scenario that in this case doesn’t live up to the hype. I obviously don’t want to give away the ending, but suffice to say I thought it lacked the massive climax that it deserved. I thought that the ending sort of just petered out to nothing and I was left feeling unsatisfied.
That said, it was the only thing that Kellerman did wrong here. His characters were interesting and full of dark secrets that kept me on the edge of my seat turning pages as quickly as I could manage. Moreland was an intriguing but distant character that was clearly hiding something big. His interaction with others was great at giving clues to his secret and I really felt that I was attempting to solve the mystery alongside Alex Delaware.
The setting for the story couldn’t have been more appropriate. Although on the face of it, Knife Island is a little piece of paradise in the middle of nowhere, right from the moment that the Delawares stepped off the boat, it was clear that something was amiss. Knife Island was described very successfully as a beautiful but chilling place that had a very dark history and many awful stories to tell.
Overall I would have to say that this book had a lot of promise that it just didn’t quite live up to. This kind of story has to have a really powerful ending to make you really sit back and wonder, but in my opinion Kellerman didn’t manage to accomplish this time.